Sell Tiffany Jewelry

Free Tiffany jewelry appraisal

Sell your Tiffany & Co. jewelry

Your Tiffany jewelry appraisal is free and without obligation to sell. We respect your confidentiality. 
You can benefit from the appraisal of all collections from the Maison Tiffany & Co..

The history of Tiffany & Co.

It was in 1837 that the first Tiffany boutique opened in New York. From a simple New York luxury jewelry boutique, Tiffany would quickly become one of the first luxury boutiques worldwide, pioneering on many fronts.

For example, it was Tiffany that first published its sales catalog (the famous Blue Book) in the United States to present its jewelry collection. It was also Tiffany that first brought luxury within reach of Americans, when Charles Lewis Tiffany bought diamonds from European aristocrats to resell them in the United States in 1848. It was also Tiffany that established the 925/1000 standard for Sterling silver, now widespread in the United States.

Many prominent figures were quick to purchase Tiffany jewelry, such as President Abraham Lincoln in 1862 (worn by his wife at the inaugural ball).

Throughout its history, the Maison Tiffany has distinguished itself by its choices regarding diamonds and precious stones; it was the first jeweler to count a gemologist among its collaborators.

In 1868, Tiffany began creating gold jewelry; and in 1878, the company acquired the most beautiful diamond in the world, a 287.42-carat yellow diamond (the Tiffany Diamond, today displayed in the flagship store on Fifth Avenue opened in 1940, and admired by over 300 visitors per day!). In 1886, the Maison Tiffany presented its first engagement ring, the Tiffany® Setting, a ring with a six-prong setting and a magnificent diamond, which would become iconic. In 1887, Charles Lewis Tiffany even went so far as to acquire the Crown Jewels of France, which were set in Tiffany jewelry and sold to American aristocrats.

Tiffany would subsequently continue to introduce new precious stones into its creations, such as tanzanite and tsavorite.

In 1902, Charles Lewis Tiffany was succeeded by his son, Louis Comfort Tiffany, at the head of the company. He distinguished himself with his Art Nouveau style and colorful jewelry. During the 20th century, the Maison counted new creators, such as Gene Moore, Jean Schlumberger, and Elsa Peretti, who breathed new life and whimsy into jewelry creations.

More original collections emerged, such as the Diamonds by the Yard collection (diamond jewelry suitable for everyday wear), or the Graffiti collection by Paloma Picasso (with graphic jewelry inspired by street art).

Tiffany & Co. is today a globally recognizable brand, with its characteristic blue that even inspired a Pantone shade (1837 Blue). It is committed to several causes, such as environmental causes, protection of endangered animals, and preservation of the Great Barrier Reef in Australia, notably through its foundation. It can even be found in the home with its new Maison and Accessories line, or in the bathroom with its perfume collection!

Tiffany & Co., a passion for gemstones

From its beginnings, the Maison Tiffany distinguished itself by its choice of gemstones. Charles Lewis Tiffany (nicknamed "the King of Diamonds") was not only a true gemstone enthusiast but also an insatiably curious man. Equipped with a team of gemologists, the jeweler was able to discover new gemstones (notably colored stones, rare at the time) and incorporate them into his jewelry for unique creations: kunzite, tanzanite, morganite, tsavorite…

Moreover, Charles Lewis Tiffany and his successors were committed to making these gems accessible to the greatest number, importing stones to the United States for their American clients, and creating collections for everyday wear. Tiffany is the iconic jewelry of popular culture, with ambassadors such as Audrey Hepburn, Marilyn Monroe, or, more recently, Lady Gaga. All Americans can even boast of owning a Tiffany creation, since the seal of the United States on banknotes was created by the Maison…

If you too own a piece of jewelry from the Maison Tiffany, you can sell it using the dedicated sales form on this page.

The Tiffany® Setting, an iconic engagement ring since 1886

Created in 1886 by Charles Lewis Tiffany, the Tiffany® Setting is the most famous engagement ring in the world. Its six-prong setting, revolutionary at the time, lifts the diamond above the band to maximize light reflection; the minimalist design and thin band leave the stone fully showcased. The mountings are most often in platinum—the house's preferred metal—or 18-karat white gold, set with fine diamonds (colors D to F, clarities IF to VVS), from half a carat to several carats.

It is also the most sought-after Tiffany piece on the resale market: its global fame ensures a sustained second-hand value. As a rough order of magnitude, on the early 2025 market, a one-carat Tiffany Setting (color D, clarity VVS1) in platinum traded between €4,500 and €7,500 for buyback; only an individual appraisal of the ring can establish a final price.

What determines the buyback price of a Tiffany piece

Our gemologists evaluate each piece according to precise criteria:

• The model and collection: the Tiffany Setting and creations by Jean Schlumberger or Elsa Peretti retain a particularly high resale value; the T, HardWear, Victoria, Atlas, Soleste or Novo collections are also sought after.
• The materials: platinum, white gold, yellow gold or rose gold—each metal has its own valuation, with platinum being the most valuable.
• The diamonds and stones: carat weight, color, clarity and cut quality (the 4Cs) largely determine the value.
• Authenticity and accessories: a GIA certificate can add up to 15% premium; the original blue box and invoice also enhance the estimate.
• Condition: scratches, deformations or worn prongs affect the price.
• Rarity: limited editions, vintage pieces or discontinued models benefit from a premium.

Recognizing an authentic Tiffany piece

Before any offer, authenticity is verified point by point: the “Tiffany & Co.” hallmark engraved inside the band with the metal purity; the diamond carat weight, usually also engraved; the serial numbers ensuring traceability; the quality of the setting—six perfectly aligned prongs on a Setting—and the finishing; finally the certificates (GIA) and original documentation. Our gemologists compare each piece with the house’s references and appraise all eras, including vintage pieces, which can reach a higher collectible value.